| Platinum | McAlister's Deli |
| Gold | The Caffeinated Cook |
| Silver | Hive |
| Bronze | Bloomingfoods |
| Top Pick | Bloomington Bagel Co |
| Top Pick | Butch's Grillactessen & Eatzeria |
| Top Pick | Darn Good Soup |
| Top Pick | Pilis Party Deli |
| Top Pick | Rush Hour Station |
| Top Pick | The Owlery Restaurant |
