| Platinum | Little Whippersnappers |
| Gold | The Prep School |
| Silver | MCCSC Early Learning |
| Bronze | Bloomington Developmental Learning Center |
| Top Pick | ABC Academy |
| Top Pick | Carousel Christian Day Care |
| Top Pick | Jill's House Intergenerational Preschool |
| Top Pick | Monroe County Head Start |
| Top Pick | Monroe County United Ministries |
| Top Pick | Sare Road KinderCare |