| Platinum | Landmark Collision Repair Center |
| Gold | Andy Mohr Honda |
| Silver | Cross Paint & Body Shop |
| Bronze | Minton Body Shop |
| Top Pick | American Eagle Auto Glass |
| Top Pick | Auto Body Specialists |
| Top Pick | Bloomington Collision Center |
| Top Pick | Curry Auto Center |
| Top Pick | Curry Collision Center |
| Top Pick | Southern Indiana Collision & Customs |