| Platinum | Jiffy Treet |
| Gold | Peach Cobbler Factory |
| Silver | Bedrak Cafe |
| Bronze | Weirdough Cookie Co. |
| Top Pick | Dairy Queen |
| Top Pick | Feast Market & Cellar |
| Top Pick | Hardscrabble Bakehouse |
| Top Pick | Piccoli Dolci |
| Top Pick | Rainbow Bakery |
| Top Pick | Two Sticks Bakery |
| Bruster's Ice Cream |