| Platinum | Phat Daddy's |
| Gold | Carson's BBQ & Catering Service |
| Gold | Smokin' Jack's Rib Shack |
| Silver | Buffa Louie's at the Gables |
| Bronze | Big D's BBQ |
| Top Pick | Great White Smoke |
| Top Pick | Hoosier Daddy's BBQ |
| Top Pick | Sahm's Clubhouse |
| Top Pick | Short Stop Food Mart BBQ Train |
| Top Pick | SmokeWorks |