| Platinum | The Caffeinated Cook |
| Gold | Crumble Coffee & Bakery |
| Silver | Two Sticks Bakery |
| Bronze | Hopscotch Coffee Roastery / to-Go |
| Top Pick | Americano Coffee |
| Top Pick | Bloomington Farm Stop |
| Top Pick | Brightside Cafe |
| Top Pick | Hive |
| Top Pick | Needmore |
| Top Pick | Rainbow Bakery |