| Platinum | Weirdough Cookie Co. |
| Gold | Baked! |
| Silver | Crumble Coffee & Bakery |
| Bronze | Chickadee Bakery |
| Top Pick | Blondie's Cookies |
| Top Pick | Bloomington Bagel Co |
| Top Pick | Crumbl Cookies - Bloomington |
| Top Pick | Ginger Nest |
| Top Pick | Insomnia Cookies |
| Top Pick | Rainbow Bakery |