| Platinum | Lennie's |
| Platinum | Phat Daddy's |
| Gold | McAlister's Deli |
| Silver | Penn Station East Coast Subs |
| Bronze | The Caffeinated Cook |
| Top Pick | Big D's BBQ |
| Top Pick | Carson's BBQ & Catering Service |
| Top Pick | Jersey Mike's Subs |
| Top Pick | Malibu Grill |
| Top Pick | Yogi's Bar & Grill |